Heal All Salve vs. Heal All Lip Balm: Which One Should You Choose?

Quick Answer

Choose Heal All Salve for multi-purpose skin healing on body, hands, and minor wounds, and reach for a lip-specific balm if you want a convenient, concentrated treatment for chapped lips. However, note that Earth Mother Medicinals currently offers Heal All Salve but does not list a dedicated 'Heal All Lip Balm' in its catalog; our comparison focuses on how the salve can serve lip care versus other balm options.

When your lips are cracked or your skin is irritated, it’s tempting to grab whatever salve is nearby. But not all herbal balms are created equal. Earth Mother Medicinals offers a Heal All Salve that claims to 'heal all' skin complaints, but does that include your lips? In this comparison, we break down what the Heal All Salve actually does, how it might work for lip care, and when you might want a dedicated lip balm instead.

We’ll look at the ingredients, texture, and intended uses, and be honest about the fact that there is no separate 'Heal All Lip Balm' in the store right now. That means you’ll need to decide whether the salve is versatile enough to double as a lip treatment or if a different product is a better match for your needs.

Heal All Salve: Ingredients and Intended Use

Earth Mother Medicinals formulates Heal All Salve with calendula flower, plantain leaf, comfrey leaf, and pure therapeutic-grade lavender and tea tree essential oils. These botanicals are known in herbalism for soothing, mending, cleaning, and promoting healing for skin complaints. The salve is designed for general skin issues—dry patches, minor cuts, rashes, or chapped areas—and can be applied generously to larger areas.

Because it’s a salve, the texture is thicker and oil-based, which helps lock in moisture and create a barrier. That same thickness can be beneficial on lips, but it also means the product is not as portable or precise as a lip balm tube. You’ll likely need to apply it with a clean finger, which is fine at home but less convenient on the go.

• Apply a thin layer to lips before bed for overnight repair.
• Use on hands, elbows, or cuticles for all-over moisture.

Lip Balm: What to Expect from a Dedicated Lip Product

A dedicated lip balm typically comes in a twist-up tube or small pot, making it easy to toss in a pocket or purse. It usually contains a blend of oils, butters, and waxes to create a firmer texture that stays put on lips. Ingredients like shea butter, beeswax, or coconut oil are common, though Earth Mother Medicinals does not currently offer a specific 'Heal All Lip Balm.'

If you prefer a product formulated specifically for lips, you may need to look elsewhere or use the Heal All Salve as a DIY alternative. The lack of a dedicated lip balm is a limitation to note: the salve’s essential oils—especially tea tree—might be too strong for sensitive lips, so a gentler formula could be safer for daily use.

• Look for lip balms with gentle, food-grade ingredients if you have sensitive lips.
• Avoid balms with added flavors if you prefer unscented options.

Direct Comparison: Heal All Salve vs. (Hypothetical) Heal All Lip Balm

Since there’s no official lip balm from Earth Mother Medicinals, we compare the Heal All Salve to what a typical lip balm offers. The salve’s key advantage is its multi-purpose nature—one jar can serve your entire body. For lips, however, the texture is richer and more likely to feel heavy, and the presence of tea tree oil could cause tingling or irritation on cracked lips.

A dedicated lip balm, on the other hand, is designed with a lower concentration of active essential oils and often contains emollients that soften and smooth the lip surface. If you need a simple, greasy-free option for daily lip care, a balm might be more comfortable. If you want a versatile healing product that can also treat lips occasionally, the salve is the better value.

• Use the salve for body and lips only when needed, not as a daily lip moisturizer.
• If you have a history of sensitive skin, patch-test the salve on your arm first.

Trade-Offs to Consider

• Convenience: Heal All Salve comes in a jar, so you’ll need a finger or a small spatula to apply. A lip balm tube is more portable and hygienic for on-the-go use. Choose a balm if convenience is your top priority; choose the salve if you don’t mind the extra step.
• Ingredient Intensity: The salve’s tea tree and lavender oils are potent. While they help fight infection, they can be irritating on already cracked lips. Lip balms usually have milder essential oil concentrations. If your lips are very sensitive, opt for a gentler lip-specific product.
• Value and Versatility: One jar of Heal All Salve can treat your hands, elbows, cuticles, and occasional chapped lips. A dedicated lip balm is single-purpose but often cheaper per use. Consider how often you’ll use each product and where—at home or on the go.

Product Facts: What the Catalog Says

• Heal All Salve: This therapeutic herbal salve (cream) soothes, mends, cleans, and promotes healing for all skin complaints. Contains calendula flower, plantain leaf, comfrey leaf, and pure therapeutic-grade lavender and tea tree essential oils. The combination of calendula, plantain, and comfrey is traditionally used for wound healing and skin repair, while lavender and tea tree provide antimicrobial support. This makes it a strong candidate for minor cuts, dry patches, and chapped lips—but the essential oils may be strong for sensitive lips.
• Earth Mother Medicinals Gift Card: Give the gift of wellness with the Earth Mother Medicinals Gift Card, available through Iris Herbals. Choose from denominations of $25, $50, $100, $200, or $500 so the recipient can select their preferred herbal products. If you’re unsure whether a friend or family member would prefer a salve or a dedicated lip balm, a gift card lets them choose the product that fits their routine best.

Which One Should You Choose?

Best for

• Anyone who wants a multi-purpose healing salve for various skin issues, including occasional lip care.
• People who prefer a single product for the whole family and don’t mind the jar format.

Not for

• Those who need a convenient, pocket-sized lip treatment for frequent use.
• Individuals with hyper-sensitive lips that react strongly to essential oils like tea tree or lavender.

In the end, the Heal All Salve is a versatile herbal remedy that can step in for lip care when needed, but it isn’t a dedicated lip balm. If you value simplicity and multi-use, the salve is a solid choice. If you want a product specifically designed for lips and easy portability, look for a gentle lip balm—or consider an Earth Mother Medicinals Gift Card to let the recipient decide.